TSMP’s client secures major win in Healthstats dispute

CLOSE

Directory

Thio Shen Yi, SC

Joint Managing Partner

Litigation

Stefanie Yuen Thio

Joint Managing Partner

Corporate

Derek Loh

Partner

Litigation

Jennifer Chia

Partner

Corporate

Melvin Chan

Partner

Litigation

Ian Lim

Partner

Litigation

June Ho

Partner

Corporate

Kelvin Koh

Partner

Litigation

Ong Pei Ching

Partner

Litigation

Mark Jacobsen

Partner

Corporate

Felicia Tan

Partner

Litigation

Jeffrey Chan, SC

Senior Director

Litigation

Prof Tang Hang Wu, PhD

Consultant

Litigation

Prof Hans Tjio

Consultant

Corporate

Kenneth Chua

Director

Litigation

Mijung Kim

Director

Litigation

Tania Chin

Director

Litigation

Leon Lim

Director

Corporate

Nanthini Vijayakumar

Director

Litigation

Nicholas Ngo

Associate Director

Litigation

Kevin Elbert

Associate Director

Litigation

Timothy Yong

Associate Director

Litigation

Eugene Neo

Associate Director

Litigation

Benjamin Bala

Associate Director

Litigation

Vu Lan Nguyen

Associate Director

Litigation

Stephanie Chew

Associate Director

Litigation

Ernest Low

Associate Director

Corporate

Elizabeth Tan

Associate Director

Litigation

Crystal Tan Shi Ying

Associate Director

Litigation

Brenda Chow

Senior Associate

Corporate

Heather Chong

Senior Associate

Corporate

Nicole Lee

Senior Associate

Corporate

Tay Quan Li

Senior Associate

Litigation

Lyn Toh Leng

Senior Associate

Corporate

Angela Chai Rui Min

Senior Associate

Litigation

Arthur Chin Yen Bing

Senior Associate

Litigation

Joshua Phang Shih Ern

Senior Associate

Litigation

Chow Jian Hui

Senior Associate

Corporate

Jeanne Goh Enchi

Senior Associate

Litigation

Lau Tin Yi

Senior Associate

Corporate

Phoon Wuei

Senior Associate

Litigation

Terence Yeo

Senior Associate

Litigation

Juliana Lake

Senior Associate

Litigation

Kashib Shareef bin Ahmad Hussain

Associate

Corporate

Goh Min Yi

Associate

Corporate

Sherlyn Lim Li Xuan

Associate

Litigation

Vanessa Cheong Shu Qi

Associate

Corporate

Lee Shu Zhen

Associate

Corporate

Nikita Garg

Associate

Litigation

Annabelle Lee Jia Xin

Associate

Corporate

Ang Kai Le

Associate

Litigation

Glenn Ng Qiheng

Associate

Litigation

Isaac Tay Zhuo Yan

Associate

Litigation

Markus Low Yu Wen

Associate

Corporate

Nicholas Fu Wei Jun

Associate

Litigation

Krisly Aw Jiaxin

Associate

Corporate

Shawn Tan Yi Wei

Associate

Corporate

Stasia Ong Pei Qi

Associate

Litigation

Sarah Kim Mun Jeong

Associate

Litigation

News

25 February 2019

TSMP’s client secures major win in Healthstats dispute

Features Ong Pei Ching

A team comprising Adrian Tan, Ong Pei Ching and Joel Goh from TSMP represented a client in a dispute in November 2018. The Court just issued its decision, which was reported in The Straits Times (Singapore Law Watch link). A summary of the case is produced below.

Introduction

The founders and former directors of HealthSTATS International Pte Ltd (“Healthstats”), a medical device company, sued two directors of Healthstats. They accused the two directors of trying to pass the trade secrets of Healthstats to a third party. They sought leave to commence a statutory derivative action against the two directors, sought leave to access Healthstats’s premises and records to obtain documents relating to the third party, and sought an interim injunction against all dealings between Healthstats and the third party.

We successfully acted for the 2nd Defendant, Mr Lian Chin Chiang, in resisting the Plaintiffs’ application. We explained to the Court that there was no evidence that the two directors were trying to pass Healthstats’s trade secrets to a third party. Indeed, as directors nominated by the majority shareholder of Healthstats, it did not make sense for them to deprive Healthstats of its main asset. When we explained that the interim injunction sought by the Plaintiffs was flawed as a matter of law, the Plaintiffs withdrew its application for the interim injunction.

Facts

The Plaintiffs, Dr Ting Choon Meng and Mr Chua Ngak Hwee, were the founders and former directors of Healthstats. The Defendants, Mr Lian Chin Chiang and Mr Chang Hon Yee, were directors appointed by the majority shareholder of Healthstats. Dr Ting and Mr Chua alleged that Mr Lian and Mr Chang breached their fiduciary duties to Healthstats.

Dr Ting and Mr Chua alleged that Mr Lian and Mr Chang were collaborating with an Australian company, Planet Innovation Pty Ltd (“PI”), to pass Healthstats’s trade secrets to PI. They accused Mr Lian and Mr Chang of removing them as directors of Healthstats for this purpose.

Healthstats, Mr Lian, and Mr Chang resisted the Plaintiffs’ application. The Plaintiffs’ application was not brought in good faith. They were not suing in Healthstats’s best interests. Instead, they had a personal vendetta. They wanted to retaliate against their removal as directors of Healthstats and try to wrest back control over the company. In executing this personal vendetta, they were willing to even harm Healthstats.

Decision

Judicial Commissioner Ang Cheng Hock (“JC Ang”) dismissed the Plaintiffs’ application entirely.

JC Ang held that the Plaintiffs failed on both limbs of the requirement of good faith under Section 216A of the CA. First, there was no merit to the application as the Plaintiffs did not have the honest or reasonable belief that they had a good cause of action for the company to prosecute. Second, they were bringing the derivative action for a collateral purpose. JC Ang found that the Plaintiff’s actions were so clouded with personal considerations as to amount to a lack of good faith for the purposes of Section 216A of the CA.

JC Ang observed that the Plaintiffs displayed a lack of candour and honesty. They claimed that they were kept in the dark from Healthstats’s negotiations with PI. But they were consistently copied in those negotiations and even participated in them. Indeed, they even had access to all the outgoing emails of the company even long after they were removed from the Company. JC Ang also found that the Plaintiffs did not have any evidence for the many allegations which they made. For example, they accused Mr Lian and Mr Chang of failing to protect Healthstats’s trade secrets, but they could not produce evidence of this failure. JC Ang found that the Plaintiffs’ allegations were purely speculative.

In sum, JC Ang found that the Plaintiffs did not have an arguable or even plausible case. In fact, there had been many opportunities for the Plaintiffs to clarify any suspicions they had. Representatives of PI repeatedly reached out to the Plaintiffs to explain and clear up any misunderstanding. But the Plaintiffs refused any such attempt.

Comment

The Court’s decision reaffirms the requirements for an application under Section 216A of the CA – the application must display good faith and that the application is prima facie in the interests of the company. These requirements thus remain important safeguards that prevent the abuse of S 216A by aggrieved parties who only wish to serve their own agendas.

The underlying purpose of Section 216A of the CA is to do justice to the company. It must not to be used as a weapon by “loud but unreasonable dissidents attempting to drive the corporate vehicle from the back seat”, thereby hampering management decisions.